type

  • Feature Article
  • Podcast
  • Research

theme

  • Instant Activity
  • Food Literacy
  • Outdoor Learning
  • Physically Active Learning
  • Social Emotional Learning
  • Cross-Curricular Learning
  • Models-Based Approach
  • PHE Community
  • Healthy School Communities
  • Fundamental Movement Skills
  • Dance Education
  • Digital Literacy
  • Health Education
  • Financial Literacy
  • Physical Education
  • Sex Education
  • Educational Leadership
  • Equity, Diversity and Inclusion
  • Teacher Education
  • Mental Health
  • Substance Use
  • Truth & Reconciliation

Search Results

SORT BY:

Physical Education: A Right or a Privilege?

September 29, 2017
a teacher leaned over talking to 4 of her students during gym class. She is holding a orange basketball and they are all standing in a gymnasium.

Previously published in Volume 83, Issue 3

Recently, I was a supply teacher at an elementary school and I overheard a comment that really bothered me. During an afternoon nutrition break I was responsible for supervising three different classrooms while they finished their lunches. The grade 5 classroom was particularly loud and I could tell by surveying the room that students had a lot of energy that needed to be released. Most of them were out of their seats either socializing with friends or running between the desks counting down the minutes until the recess bell rang.

While I was in this classroom trying to keep the peace a teacher walked in and said, “This afternoon we have science and physical education. If you aren’t quiet and cooperative during science than we are not having physical education.”

I immediately heard a few students moaning and one boy mumbled, “That’s not fair!”

Shortly after the teacher left, the recess bell rang and there was a swarm of students making their way out of the classroom and down the hall to enjoy a beautiful sunny day.

As I walked to the staff room to get my lunch I pondered to myself, "Is physical education a right or a privilege?". This prompted a whole slew of questions: Why are teachers threatening to take away one of the most important subjects? What kind of message does this send to students about the importance of PE? Why are math, literacy and science viewed as “untouchable subjects” that are never shortchanged? Should I have intervened after the teacher spoke and said, “What your teacher meant to say was that if you finish the science task for today there is a possibility everyone can go outside for physical education a bit early?"

As a health and physical educator and advocate my personal opinions are biased. I have always loved being physically active. It is my hope to instill this passion and love for PE to the teacher candidates I teach. I enjoy being a positive and healthy role model to my one-year-old daughter and three-year-old son. My personal opinions aside, it's becoming impossible to ignore the growing bodies of research stating the plethora of health benefits associated with being physically active. In fact, there is incontrovertible evidence that regular physical activity contributes to the primary and secondary prevention of several chronic diseases and is associated with a reduced risk of premature death. (Warburton, Nicol, & Bredin, 2006, p. 807).

a black man who is a physical education teacher is stretching with 3 of his students. Two are standing with one arm over their head and another is in a wheelchair.

I love showing teacher candidates how to facilitate physical education because there is so much more to PE than sports. On the first day after I meet each student and introduce myself I ask my class to stand up and repeat after me.

“I will never take away PE because my class is misbehaving."

After the class repeats my PE pledge we discuss why physical education is so important and what kind of experiences students had in elementary and high school. I am always shocked how many teacher candidates raise their hands when I ask, “How many of you had a negative PE experience when you were younger?”. It breaks my heart to hear the reasons behind the anxiety, hesitation and hatred towards PE based on their prior experiences. The common responses I hear include: it was boring, all we did was run laps, it was too competitive, my teacher didn’t participate, I didn’t feel good enough, we only played dodge ball, I always got a low mark, I was never taught the skills, it was an unsupportive environment and there was a lack of passion.

Although it is difficult to change minds, attitudes and negative feelings I do my best by providing an open and supportive learning environment where teacher candidates can grow, learn and try new activities in a fun and non-judgmental space.

When teachers understand the positive impact physical education can have on growing bodies and minds, taking it away seems both counterintuitive and counterproductive. I have found that classrooms full of students who are loud, misbehaving, or having a hard time focusing need PE even more! Incorporating physical activity into the day positively impacts learning and behavior in the classroom (Morgan. P. J., & Hansen, V. 2008). I understand that teachers have an incredible amount of subjects and content to cover, however taking physical activity breaks during the day can really help improve on task behavior during academic instruction (Mahar, M. T. et al. 2006). So I end with the question, "Do you believe PE is a right or a privilege? And how can we shift school culture to value and appreciate health and physical education?"

References

Mahar, M. T., Murphy, S. K., Rowe, D. A., Golden, J., Shields, A. T., & Raedeke, T. D.

(2006). Effects of a classroom-based program on physical activity and on-task behavior. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 38(12), 2086-2094.

Morgan, P. J., & Hansen, V. (2008). Physical education in primary schools: Classroom teachers’ perceptions of benefits and outcomes. Health Education Journal, 67(3), 196-207.

Warburton, D. E., Nicol, C. W., & Bredin, S. S. (2006). Health benefits of physical activity: The evidence. CMAJ. 174(6), 801-809.

Recent Posts

wooden blocks with faces drawn on them
Creating a Mindful Community: How Parents, Teachers, and Students Can Work Together to Promote Mental Health
[ Feature Article ] Mental health is a critical aspect of a student’s overall well-being, and emphasizing the importance of mental health aligns with the “Living Well” facet of the Canadian Physical and Health Education Competencies (Davis et al., 2023). Creating a supportive, mindful environment that engages teachers, parents, and students can make a world of difference.
Authored by: Brenna Wyman
child catching a balloon
Balloons: Adding Accomplishment, Joy, and Challenge for Physical Education Students
[ Feature Article ] Balloons are an often-overlooked gem in the world of Physical Education (PE). Not only are they inexpensive, but they stay afloat for much longer than most balls, giving students ample time to strike, catch, and improve their coordination. Balloons are also versatile and offer a fun way to develop physical literacy while playing games that are engaging for students of all ages.
Authored by: Dr. John Byl
A woman engages with a group of individuals in a library setting, fostering discussion and collaboration among them.
Emerging Scholars – Where are they now?
[ Feature Article ] Since 2015, PHE Canada’s Research Council has honored graduate students with the Emerging Scholar Award for excellence in teaching, research, and leadership. As the 2025 Research Forum approaches, past recipients shared how the award shaped their careers, their proudest recent work, the value of staying connected to the Council, and advice for future scholars.
Authored by: Martha Gumprich
children playing soccer outdoors
Connecting Communities Through Movement: There’s Strength in Numbers
[ Feature Article ] During the early days of the pandemic, I pitched my idea to the administration at Larkhall Academy: an initiative designed to keep our school community engaged in movement. This initiative would be simple enough for anyone—students, staff, or community members—to participate in, and it would take very little time to complete. I named it Time to Move.
Authored by: Jody Worthman
1 teacher and 8 students behind her
The True Sport Experience: A values-based tool for educators
[ Feature Article ] Can you tell us a little about The True Sport Experience and what inspired the development of this resource? The True Sport Experience is a three-volume resource designed for educators working with...
Authored by: Sarah Bennett
Several people in canoes are positioned on the shore, engaging in recreational activities by the water's edge.
Sharing Teaching Experiences (Part Three): Logistics of Studying PHE Abroad
[ Feature Article ] This is the third and final article in a series about two teacher education programs, Western Norway University of Applied Sciences (HVL) in Norway and Mount Royal University (MRU) in Calgary, collaboration in the field of Physical and Outdoor Education in teacher education. Written by three teacher educators, these articles are useful to those in the PHE field(s) in schools and in higher education. They demonstrate how there is much to learn from looking beyond our own borders through international partnerships engagement which can support everyone’s professional development, practice and pedagogy, philosophies of learning and teaching, and friendships.
Authored by: Dr. Shannon Kell