type

  • Feature Article
  • Podcast
  • Research

theme

  • Instant Activity
  • Food Literacy
  • Outdoor Learning
  • Physically Active Learning
  • Social Emotional Learning
  • Cross-Curricular Learning
  • Models-Based Approach
  • PHE Community
  • Healthy School Communities
  • Fundamental Movement Skills
  • Dance Education
  • Digital Literacy
  • Health Education
  • Financial Literacy
  • Physical Education
  • Sex Education
  • Educational Leadership
  • Equity, Diversity and Inclusion
  • Teacher Education
  • Mental Health
  • Substance Use
  • Truth & Reconciliation

Search Results

SORT BY:

Beyond the 1 in 5: Bringing Awareness to the Needs of all of our Children and Youth

February 19, 2018
two children with one of their arms around the other while they look off in the distance at the water

Beyond the 1 in 5: Bringing Awareness to the Needs of all of our Children and Youth

We hear the oft-repeated statistic that 1 in 5 of our young people will experience a mental health disorder. But too often, we do not go beyond what that data says, to ask ourselves if it actually reflects the reality of what we experience with our young people on a daily basis. 

Research came in, back in the 1980’s, reflecting that epidemiologists and child psychiatrists were pointing to the fact that, on standardized checklists and psychological inventories, an estimated 20 % of 4 to 18-year-old children and youth would present as having a diagnosable mental health disorder (Rae-Grant, Offord, and Boyle, 1989). What that data actually reflected was, compared to children and youth of the same sex and age, a certain number of young people would give clinical evidence of depression, anxiety etc. What this really meant was that on a specific standardized measure, a certain percentage of young people would perform in a certain way that was markedly different than many others.  

And this logic and evidence have been used to reflect what the clinical needs are of young people and the extent of services and treatment that is required. 

But does it reflect the nature and level of need in our students that we know as teachers to be true on a daily basis? 

A good friend and colleague of mine, Dr. Gordon Flett of York University, uses the phrase “flying under the radar of detection” in characterizing those youth who, while they may not measure up to the standard of prior research as being among the 1 in 5, nonetheless, present to us as experiencing sadness, social anxiety, and mistrust, along with other vulnerabilities (Flett, and Hewitt, 2013).  

We need to move beyond the 1 in 5; it does not reflect the reality of the subclinical threshold of the needs of our children and youth who also require our care and concern. 

Problematic as well is the belief that, if the 1 in 5 represents those children and youth who meet diagnosable levels of distress, then we can ignore the others as simply experiencing a ‘passing phase’ or diminish its significance as simply an ‘adjustment reaction of adolescence’.

The vast majority of mental health challenges that teachers will experience in their students will be situational; reactive to a life event, and not necessarily representative of a prolonged period of distress or debilitating illness. It may be the grief and sadness in a child whose first experience of death comes at the loss of a grandparent, or the reaction of a grade nine student whose awkwardness in trying to establish social connections has been met with rejection. 

And what we know regarding what young people in these contexts need from us is a listening ear, a kind voice, and a genuine measure of concern, along with the reassurance that, no, their world is not falling apart, and that with perspective and time, they will learn a life lesson from their experience and move on. 

child looking off in the distance

I believe there has been some confusion in what the school-based mental health movement has conjured in the minds of some. We are not looking for educators to become psychologists. Where we think, however, with support and education, that teachers can make an incredible difference, is being part of a system of care. When necessary, that system of care can allow for immediate intervention when the situation calls for it, and / or the identification of further services and interventions where an educator who is competently literate in mental health in children and youth can identify a need and have the resources to support their concern (Doll, Nastasi, Cornell and Song, 2017).  

As for the vast majority of children and youth that teachers come into contact with who experience emotional or behavioural distress, embracing the belief that a little bit of the right service, provided at the right time by a trusted adult can head off an escalating sense of vulnerability in many of our children and youth is supported in fact and evidence (Tegethjoff, Stalujanis, Belardi, and Meinischmidt, 2014). 

Moreover, if that system of care becomes an integral part of a child or youth’s educational experience, we can promote resiliency and an increased competency if, in a future occasion, a coping strategy that had once been learned was used again when it was needed. 

References

Doll, B., Nastasi, B.K., Cornell, L. & Song, S.Y. (2017). School-based mental health services: Definitions and models of effective practice. Journal of Applied School Psychology, 33,     179-194. 

Flett, G. & Hewitt, P. (2013). Disguised Distress in Children and Adolescents “Flying Under The Radar” Why Psychological Problems Are Underestimated and How Schools Must     Respond. Canadian Journal of School Psychology, 28, 12-27. 

Rae-Grant N, Thomas F, Offord D, Boyle M (1989). Risk, protective factors, and the prevalence of behavioral and emotional disorders in children and adolescents. Journal of the American Academy of Child Adolescent Psychiatry, 28, 262-268

Tegethjoff, M., Stalujanis, E., Belardi, A. & Meinischmidt, G. (2014). School mental health services: Signposts for out of school service utilization in adolescents with mental health disorders? A Nationally representative United States Cohort. PLoS ONE [http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0099675]
 

 

Recent Posts

A group of children joyfully playing soccer in a sunny park, with trees and grass in the background.
Activating Schools as a Key Driver in Federal Sport Policy - A PHE Canada Advocacy Report
[ Feature Article ] This advocacy report, prepared for the Future of Sport in Canada Commission, positions schools as a critical driver in shaping the future of Canada’s sport policy. It argues that school-based physical...
Authored by: PHE Canada
a group of kids outdoors in uniforms holding up a girl in celebration
Igniting Self-Leadership in PHE Through the Language of Captain and Poet: A Social-Emotional Learning (SEL) Strategy
[ Feature Article ] The integration of Social Emotional Learning (SEL) into PHE represents a unique opportunity to enhance students' development of critical life skills. Unlike traditional classroom settings, PHE offers immediate feedback on how our actions contribute to performance, teamwork, leadership, success, and failure, in real time. The simple language of Captain and Poet is being introduced into schools to help students (and their teachers) better understand their innate strengths alongside how they are showing up for themselves and others. PHE offers a powerful opportunity to heighten self-leadership skills and empower young people to make decisions, communicate, collaborate, and improve themselves in more effective ways.
Authored by: Jennifer Johnson
A teacher engages with a group of children in a gym setting, fostering interaction and learning.
Identifying a Quality Physical Education (QPE) Educator: A Transformative Journey
[ Feature Article ] Transforming personal growth into effective Health and Physical Education (HPE) teaching is key. With 35 years of experience, this article underscores the importance of relationship-building, student empowerment, and creating a safe, inclusive environment. Highlighting the significance of real-world relevance, personalized learning, and fostering mental health, it delineates 10 qualities that define a Quality Physical Education (QPE) educator. Embracing these traits inspires students to pursue lifelong wellness and demonstrates that educators can truly be the change they wish to see in HPE.
Authored by: Ted Temertzoglou
5 children playing in a pool with a beach ball
Beach Ball and Aquatic Games: Fun and Fitness in the Water
[ Feature Article ] This article highlights the versatility of beach balls and pool noodles in promoting fun and fitness in aquatic environments. It describes a range of engaging games for individuals, pairs, and teams that improve coordination, balance, and teamwork. From partner challenges to large group activities like water polo and aquatic basketball, each game is designed to boost water confidence and physical activity in a playful setting.
Authored by: Dr. John Byl
kids using vr
Incorporating Technology into Physical Education: Enhancing Engagement and Learning
[ Feature Article ] In today’s digital world, especially among teens, technology is everywhere. Dismissing it in Physical Education can hinder innovation and disconnect us from students’ needs (Martin & Hultman, 2022). Digital tools like gamified apps can boost motivation and engagement. Rather than resist its growth, we should embrace technology to enrich teaching and enhance student learning (Yau et al., 2022).
Authored by: Dyson MacLeod
person facing away from the camera holding a progressive pride flag
What Educators Need to Know About Alberta’s Gender Policy Legislation
[ Feature Article ] In light of Alberta’s new gender policy legislation, educators are navigating complex intersections between student well-being, parental rights and professional responsibilities. This article overviews Bill 27 highlighting what has changed, what remains, and what educators need to know to support their students with confidence and care. Rooted in learnings from the Ever Active Schools Alberta School Board Policy Clinic, it emphasizes practical strategies to mitigate harm, uphold human rights and foster inclusive learning environments.
Authored by: Kai Williamson